data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/fd42e/fd42eee6408831203c1f9bb19fdd8fc3696722d4" alt=""
That being said, this book cover is pretty ridiculous, right? I mean, the title is kind of corny, but to me the cover is beyond nerdy. This is NOT an edible book. I recently bought this book as a gift for someone since I've always enjoyed the author's intelligent, unbiased work on ESPN, and the description made it sound like a good baseball read. (My plan was to attain it for myself if it received a solid peer review.) Also, since the author has a very bizarre frog-like voice, I've always wondered whether that has affected how I viewed his reporting. Here was a chance to imagine a new, less distracting voice delivering me the same thoughtful information and analysis! But Kurkjian, what were you thinking? Having a 3/4 body picture of yourself, in a suit, with a baseball mitt? Superimposed over a much smaller stadium, giving the feeling that a giant Tim Kurkjian is taking a break from a post-production meeting to just have a catch? Just shagging some balls in the miniature outfield with some analyst buddies without unfastening a button or loosening your tie? That does not conjure images of what a great game this is - in fact, this decidedly does not look like a great game. This looks like a really lame, sad game if all of the players are wearing suits and grinning like idiots. And so many words!!! The title itself is a rhetorical question with two forms of punctuation, there is a subtitle with a dash that really makes it two subtitles, and even the author's name has a qualifier in a red box! Barf.
I did get a really good review of the book, though, and I'm already borrowing it. So I'm not entirely superficial.
BaeRating: D
1 comment:
This cover is a mess and fairly BaeRated. He could really take a cue from Fair Ball: A Fan's Case for Baseball by Bob Costas. Bob is tastefully in proportion on the third baseline and casually suited. It's not an awkward action shot; you actually believe he was just out on the field after hours reflecting on the game he loves. The ungloved mid-air ball toss is jaunty yet appropriate given his attire. B+
Post a Comment